思想史编史理论与实践的比较——以余英时《朱熹的历史世界(绪说部分)》为参照

A Comparison of Theory and Practice in Historiography of Intellectual History

选取陈来、漆侠、钱穆等学者的相关文本与《朱熹的历史世界(绪说部分)》进行比较,揭示了《绪说》与这些文本之间在思想史编史理论及其实践上有着重要差异,这些差异给思想史理论的深入研究提供了许多新的启示。

Comparing the chosen texts by Chen Iai, Qi Xia, and Qian Mu, with ＂Zhu Xi＇s Historical World＂ by Yu Ying-shi, this article argues that, from the viewpoint of the theory and practice of historiography of intellectual history, these texts differ significantly, especially in dealing with theory and practice of historiography between thoughts and history. Such differences offer valuable new inspirations to the study of the theory of intellectual history.