德国CHE大学排名及其启示被引量：15

The CHE University Ranking and Its Inspirations

下载PDF

导出

摘要从1998年开始,德国高等教育发展中心发布了CHE大学排名,这一排名在国际上引起了广泛的关注。因为在排名的内容上它关注大学教育的质量,在排名的方法上它不对大学做整体的次序排名而是针对单个学科构建了一个没有名次的排行榜,并且以分组的方式呈现各个评价指标的结果。这种独一无二的方法在一定程度上克服了传统大学排名的弊端,对德国高等教育的发展和其他国家的大学排名产生了积极的影响。CHE大学排名的理念与实践都值得我们借鉴。 The Center for Higher Education Development in Germany started to release CHE university ranking in 1998. Up to now, the ranking has gained much attention from all over the world because it dispenses with holistic ranking ordering of institutions in league tables, and assigns results of the indicators to three groups. This unique method of ranking minimized the conceptual and technical problems that often make university rankings controversial. It also exerts great influences on the Germany higher education system and the research of the university ranking. The experience of the CHE university ranking can offer some inspiring implications to the current ranking of China＇s colleges and universities.

作者熊万曦

机构地区北京师范大学教育学院

出处《比较教育研究》 CSSCI 北大核心 2008年第9期40-45,共6页 International and Comparative Education

基金教育部哲学社会科学研究(2006年度)重大课题攻关项目"大学创新力评价研究"(课题编号:06JZD0038)的中期成果之一。

关键词大学排名 CHE大学排名德国 university ranking CHE university ranking Germany

分类号 G649.516 [文化科学—高等教育学]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献12

1菲力普·G.阿尔特巴赫,周岳峰.大学排行榜之困[J].世界教育信息,2006,19(6):28-29. 被引量：3
2亚历克斯.埃舍尔,马斯莫.萨维诺,王亚敏,侯书栋,李立国.差异的世界:大学排名的全球调查[J].清华大学教育研究,2006,27(5):1-10. 被引量：24
3Terenzini & Pascarella. Living with Myths: Undergraduate Education in America. Change, 1994, Vol. 26( 1 ):28-32.
4Valerie Strauss. U.S. News's College Rankings Face Competition and Criticism. The Washington Post,2007,August 17.
5Ninavan Dyke. Twenty Years of University Report Cards. Higher Education in Europe, 2005, Vol.30 (2): 103-125.
6Maarja Soo & David Dill. The CHE University Ranking in Germany. [ EB/OL ].http://www.unc.edu/ppaq/docs/CHE_formatted.pdf, 2007.
7Gero Federkeil. The Lack of a National Policy Regime of Quality Assurance in Germany Implications and Alternatives. Higher Education Management and Policy, 2003,Vol.15(2):63-72.
8Marijkvander Wende. Ranking and Classification in Higher Education: a European Perspective. Higher Education, 2008, Vol.23: 49-71.
9Detlef Mtiller-Boling. CHE-Ranking Methodology and Presentation [EB/OL].http://www.utwente.nl/cheps/docu- menten/2005rankingmullerboling.pdf, 2005-12-02.
10Kelly Field. Another Accountability Idea: A New Database that Would Customize College Rankings. Chronicle of Higher Education, 2006, March 31.

二级参考文献46

1Education18,Internet URL at http://education18.com/
2The Financial Times.Financial Times Universities 2003,03 May 2003.
3Kelly,Jim.'Access:A gentle break with elitist traditions:Government opts for a benign regulatory framework over quotas,' p 3.'Admissions policies:A shining example to the rest:Sheffield has shown how to build a socially inclusive university and is far ahead of the government's agenda,' p 12.' How to read the tables:Large number of criteria provide stability-method produces important tool for parents and would-be students,' p 8.'London 2nd edition:Fears that ￡ 3000 top-up fee could be the norm,' p 7.--.'London 2nd edition:Review to challenge academic attitudes,' p 7.--.'London 2nd edition-school funding:Headteachers warn of ￡2.5bn black hole,' p7.--.'Top five confirm their long-held positions:But Loughborough breeds winners and edges towards the elite,' p9.--.'Vice-chancellors' survey:Higher charges seem inevitable-Questionnaire provides clear indication of how the market will look in 2006 with most institutions expected to charge an extra ￡ 3000,' p 2.
4Murray,Sarah.'Manchester merger:A marriage of love:The move to combine was driven by compelling reasons,' p 11.
5Tieman,Ross.'Cambridge/MIT:Change of tack alters emphasis-focus is now on knowledge exchange,'p 10.
6Finnie,Ross & Usher,Alex (2005).Measuring the Quality of Post-secondary Education:Concepts,Current Practices and a Strategic Plan.Kingston,Ont.:Canadian Policy Research Networks.
7Gladwell,Malcolm.'Getting in:the social logic of Ivy League admissions,' the New Yorker,10 October 2005,p80.
8The Guardian (Leach,Jimmy,editor; 2004).The Guardian University Guide 2005:What to study,where to go and how to get there.London:Atlantic Books.
9Hicks,Diana (2004) "The Four Literatures of Social Science" in Handbook of Quantitative Science and Technology Research,e.Henk Moed.,Kluwer Academic.
10Jobbins,David.'The Times/The Times Higher Education Supplement-League Tables in Britain:An Insider's View' in Higher Education in Europe,vol ⅩⅩⅦ,no 4,pp 383-388.