在我国未成年人诉讼中引入刑事和解制度的理论基础及其合理性研究——以未成年犯作为特殊被害人为视角

Disscussion on the Theoretic Foundation and Rationality on Criminal Compromise for China's Introduction in Its Criminal Procedure——In the view of juvenile as special victim

将未成年人诉讼中的刑事和解制度的理论基础概括为被害人主体地位的回归、罪刑法定原则、罪刑相当原则从绝对到相对的理念转变以及恢复性理论、平衡理论或叙说理论都是存在问题的,为在我国的未成年人审判中引入刑事和解寻找一个坚实而科学的理论依据,尚需学界同仁的坚苦努力和不懈探索,在当前,可以暂且将在我国的未成年人诉讼中引入刑事和解的理论基础建构在合理性之上。

It is questionable to recapitulate the theoretie foundation and rationality on criminal compromise for China＇s introduction in its criminal procedure as the return of the victim＇ s subject status, the principle of legislative crimes and responsibility, the conversion of punishment-be-commensurate-with-the crime principle, restorative theory, banlance theory and narrative theory. In order to make a concrete foundation for the theoretic foundation and rationality on criminal compromise for China＇s introduction in its criminal procedure, hard work is still needed, we can temporarily put the theoretic foundation of introductin of criminal compromise on the rationality.