评“自己讲”、“讲自己”的哲学史观——与张立文先生商榷

Reviews of the Viewpoints of "Self-speaking" and "Speaking of Self"——A Discussion with Mr. Zhang Liwen

近年来,走出中国哲学的合法性危机、探索中国哲学史研究的范式创新是学者们关注较多的话题。在讨论中,也出现了一些有建设性的意见。其中,著名学者张立文先生的"自己讲"、"讲自己"的观点尤其引人瞩目。张先生在此方面的系列观点,对于增进中国学者研究中国哲学的自主性来说,有一定的积极意义。然而,张先生关于"自己讲"、"讲自己"、"中国哲学转生规律"以及"和合学"的论述尚存在诸多待改进的方面。全面、客观地评价"自己讲"、"讲自己"的哲学史观,对于提高中国哲学研究的理论水平来说具有重要意义。

In recent years, many scholars have shllted attention to the topics about moving Deyona me legitimacy crisis of Chinese philosophy and trying to come up with a new research paradigm of the history of Chinese philosophy. Among the constructive suggestions that these scholars have advanced, Mr. Zhang Li-wen＇s viewpoints of ＂ self- speaking＂ and ＂speaking of self＂ are worth special attention. Mr. Zhang＇s viewpoints are of positive significance to enhancing the autonomy of the researchers of Chinese philosophers. At the same time, there are still some deficiencies in ＂self-speaking＂, ＂speaking of self＂, ＂the reincarnation law of Chinese philosophy＂ and ＂the theory of harmony＂. It is of great significance to appraise the viewpoints of ＂self-speaking＂ and ＂speaking of self＂ in a way which is both comprehensive and objective.