浅议我国印证证明模式下的自由心证

A Preliminary Discussion about Discretional Evaluation of Evidence under the Verification Mode in China

我国刑事诉讼的"印证证明模式"下的自由心证以追求案件真相为价值取向,立法制定了较高的证明标准。这导致在司法实践中缺乏可操作性,不利于发现案件真相,保护被告人的权益。在探讨自由心证制度的基础上,结合我国证据制度的实际情况,建议对我国的自由心证制度进行重构。

In China,the discretional evaluation of evidence under the verification mode in the criminal procedure values the case truth and it legislatively features relatively high standards of proof.But in judicial practices,the relatively high standards are hard to handle and with the system it is hard to find out the case truth and to protect the interests and rights of the defendant.The paper discusses the system of the discretional evaluation of evidence and suggests the restructuring of the system according to the situation of the evidence system in China.