从造船的条件要求质疑“船台说”

A Query about "Theory of Berth Site" from the View of Shipbuilding Requirement

广州"秦汉造船遗址"根本就不存在,只不过是少数人的主观臆造而已。"船台说"者采取先定性后论证及排斥不同意见的做法,具有一定的欺骗性。实际上,所谓的"造船遗址"并不具备造船的基本要素,文中提出了一系列"船台说"者无法自圆其说的问题。最后呼吁"船台说"者及政府有关部门采取实事求是的负责的态度,促成问题的早日解决。

The existence of ＂The Relic of Shipbuilding Site in Qin ＆ Han Dynasty＂ in Guangzhou is just an illusion of the minority. The ＂Berth Site Theory＂ is deceptive because its holders make conclusions before demonstrations of evidence and reject different opinions. In fact, the so-called ＂Berth Site＂ does not have any basic factors of ship-building. This paper is put forward some questions, which the holders of ＂Berth Site Theory＂ can not answer by themselves. At the end of the paper, messages are sent to the ＂Berth Site Theory＂ holders and the office of the government to ask them to be truthful and responsible so that the conflict could be solved earlier.