关于抢劫罪“两个当场”的讨论——从洪某抢劫案谈起

On "two kinds of on the scene" of the Robbery Crime

本文从洪某抢劫案出发,通过对实践中各种各样的抢劫情形的分析,以及对抢劫罪、敲诈勒索罪和绑架罪的辨析,得出抢劫罪的成立与既遂均不需要"两个当场"。并且提出主张:判断罪数的标准应当是犯罪构成客体的重合性,而不是犯罪构成。

This article embarks from the robbery about Hong,analyzes various many kinds of robbery and the differences between robbery,extortness and kidnapping,and educes the conclusion that the conviction of the Robbery Crime does not need ＂two kinds of on the scene＂. Moreover,this article proposes that the judgment standard of crime quantity should be the superposition of the criminal object,not the criminal constitution.