期刊文献+

刑法解释学的独立品格 被引量:8

The Independent Character of Criminal Law Hermeneutics…
原文传递
导出
摘要 刑法解释学属于广义刑法学的一个核心分支学科,并具有自身独立的学科品格。其独立的学科品格包括三个内在的学科独立基本要素和三个外在的学科独立条件。前者是指刑法解释权、刑法解释行为和刑法解释结论;后者包括:狭义刑法学无法涵盖刑法解释学,即刑法解释学不等同于狭义刑法学;广义刑法学本身已昭示了刑法解释学自身的独立性;刑法解释学的产生和发展遵循着法学学科独立的一般性规律。倡导刑法解释学的学科独立品格,其价值在于:推进刑法学的学科应用功能;纠偏刑法学研究者热衷于铸造恢宏的概念化法学架构而忽视刑法应用实效研究的倾向;彰显刑法解释学价值判断的实践属性。 Criminal law hermeneutics, being a core branch subject of criminal jurisprudence in broad sense, has its own separated subject characters, which include three internal basic elements and three external conditions. The former refer to the power, conduct and conclusion of criminal law interpretation. As to the three external conditions, firstly, criminal law hermeneutics can not be covered by criminal jurisprudence in narrow sense, that is, these two are different from each other. Secondly, criminal jurisprudence in broad sense has already made clear the independence of criminal law hermeneutic. Lastly, the emergence and development of criminal law hermeneutics follows the general rule of an independent legal subject. The independence of criminal law hermeneutics can promote the application function of the subject of criminal law, can rectify the tendency that researchers are keen to build the grand conceptualization frame of law, but ignore the effectiveness of the application of criminal law, and can highlight the practical attribute of its value judgment. Criminal law hermeneutics system is the organic unified system based on a certain principles and rules, including the basic theory, ontology, the application theory and the practice of criminal law hermeneutics. Advocating the independent character of criminal law hermeneutics is neither a grandstanding academic, nor an academic bias. It is urged by the integration of the theory value and application value of criminal jurisprudence, the pursuit of combining the justice of criminal legislation with the specific facts of concrete cases, and the realization of the ultimate goals of criminal law, i. e. justice, stability and harmony. Such urgencies opens up the living space and application field which the criminal law hermeneutics as a subject needs. At the same time, the power, conduct and conclusion of criminal law interpretation, as the basic elements of criminal law hermeneutics, demonstrate the self--consistent of the subject. Concerning, advocating and promoting the subject independence of criminal law hermeneutics should be regarded as positive academic pursuit, and scholars should take this as their responsibility.
作者 徐岱
出处 《法学研究》 CSSCI 北大核心 2009年第3期23-38,共16页 Chinese Journal of Law
关键词 刑法学 刑法解释学 学科独立 刑法解释学体系 criminal jurisprudence, criminal law hermeneutics, subject independence, criminal law hermeneutics system
  • 相关文献

参考文献18

  • 1孔庆平.《蔡枢衡的刑法思想研究》[A].陈兴良主编.《刑事法评论》第9卷[C].中国政法大学出版社,2001年版.第358页.
  • 2[日]野村稔 全理其 何力译.《刑法总论》[M].法律出版社,2001年版.第346-352页.
  • 3[日]大塚仁.《刑法概说》,冯军译,中国人民大学出版杜2003年版,第360页
  • 4童之伟.论宪法学新体系的基石范畴[J].法学评论,1996,14(6):15-21. 被引量:7
  • 5[美]约翰·亨利·梅利曼 顾培东 禄正平译.《大陆法系》[M].法律出版社,2004年版.第87页.第44页.
  • 6林维.《刑法解释的权力分析》,中国人民公安大学出版社2006年版,第332页.
  • 7[德]黑格尔.《逻辑学》上卷,杨一之译,商务印书馆,1966年,第1、2页.
  • 8[英]哈特 张文显等译.《法律的概念》[M].中国大百科全书出版社,1996年版.第81页.
  • 9林山田.《刑法通论》上册,台湾林山田发行2003年版,第128页.
  • 10张明楷.《法益初论》[M].中国政法大学出版社,2003年修订版.第525页以下.

二级参考文献3

共引文献686

同被引文献105

引证文献8

相关作者

内容加载中请稍等...

相关机构

内容加载中请稍等...

相关主题

内容加载中请稍等...

浏览历史

内容加载中请稍等...
;
使用帮助 返回顶部