“京房六十律”再辩

More Argue on "Jing Fang Sixty Temperament"

《前汉书.眭、两夏侯、京、翼、李列传》的"事梁人焦延寿"至"房用之尤精"一段文字中,若不同版本出现"六十卦"者当系"六十四卦"之误。京房创立"六十律"并非为了使"京房《易》学在音律学中的延伸",而是为了实现黄钟周而复始返回本律、本"均",以达到《虞书》所云"律和声"的目的。"京房六十律"并不是"在‘卦气’说的直接影响下,参照了‘卦气’说的像数模式而创立"的,而是京房受到《礼运》篇"五声、六律、十二管还相为宫"理论的启发而形成的。对于京房其人其律的评价,既不能随便贬低,也不能任意夸大,应该采取有一说一、有二说二的实事求是态度。

Base on reseach the Chinese ancient document, the writer believed that the ＂Sixty Diagrams＇in different editions error, and it should be ＂Sixty-Four Diagrams＂. To evaluate Jing Fang with his temperament system, the writer proposed that it should be in the attitude of practical and realistic, neither derogate nor exaggeration