反复上访者司法精神病鉴定案例分析

Analyses of jurisdictional identification of mental disease of 17 repeated petitioners

目的探讨反复上访者的司法精神病鉴定特点。方法采用自制调查表对17例反复上访者的鉴定资料进行分析，统计其上访动机、诊断及责任能力。结果上访动机：妄想支配7例（41．18％），现实动机9例（52．94％），不明动机1例；诊断：精神分裂症6例（35．29％），偏执性精神病2例（11．76％），无精神病5例（29．41％），其它4例；完全责任能力7例（41．18％），部分责任能力1例（5．88％），无责任能力9例（52．94％）。结论反复上访者多有精神异常，有关部门应考虑其是否具有病理性动机。

Objective To explore the characteristics of forensic psychiatry expertise of the repeated petitioners. Methods Appraisement data of 17 repeated petitioners were analyzed using Self-made Questionnaire（SMQ）, their petitioning motivations, diagnoses and responsibility added up. Results Petitioning motivations were that 7 persons（41.18%） were governed by delusion, 9（52. 94%） real motivation and 1 unknown motivation; diagnoses were that 6 （35.29 %） were diagnosed as schizophrenia, 2 （11.76 %） as paranoid psychosis,5（29.41%） without psychosis and 4 as other diagnoses;7（41.18%） had complete reponsibility,1 （5.88%） partial and 9（52.94%） irresponsibility. Conclusion Most of repeated petitioners have mental anomaly, the parties concerned should consider if they have pathological motive.