在行为不符合特别条款时能否排除普通条款的适用——从两个实际案例说起

Whether the Application of the common Provisions may be Excluded when the action doesn't conform to the special provisions:from two cases

在行为不符合特别法条规定的构成要件,但符合普通法条规定犯罪的构成要件时,由于法条之间不具有排斥关系,因而应以普通法条追究行为人刑事责任;以普通法条追究刑事责任可以实现刑法的任务;可以实现形式上的合理性,利于保护嫌疑人、被告人的合法权益。

When the action doesn＇t conform to the constituent requirements of the special legal provisions, but conforms to the constituent requirements of crime specified in the common legal provisions, as there is no exclusive relationship between the legal provisions, the actor shall be investigated for the criminal responsibility in accordance with the common legal provisions. Investigation for the criminal responsibility in accordance with the common legal provisions can realize the mission of the criminal law and can realize the formal reasonableness. It is helpful to protect the lawful right and interests of the suspect and the defendant.