试论《国家珍贵古籍名录》中的几处缺憾

Study on Some Problems of National Directory of Precious Ancient Books

论证《第一批国家珍贵古籍名录》(以下简称《名录》)中的《天盖楼四书语录》并非天盖楼刻本,探讨此书的版本情况;指出殿本《西清古鉴》应为刻本而非铜版本,论证《名录》中《西清古鉴》实为光绪年间日本铜版本;《名录》中《全唐诗》应以初印本而非后印本为佳;并探讨《第一批国家珍贵古籍名录图录》中《古文渊鉴》尚需完善的地方。

The paper argues that Tiangailous＇ Quotations on The Four Books in The First Batch of National Directory of Precious Ancient Books is not the block-printed edition of Tiangailou, and analyzes the various editions of this book, then points out the Wuyingdian edition of Ancient Xiqing Kam should be block-printed edition instead of copperplate edition, and this book in The First Batch（ short for The First Bath of National Directory of Precious Acient Books） should be Japanese copperplate edition of Guangxu period. Entire Tang Poems in The First Batch should be early printed edition instead of later. Lastly the paper points out the prolems of Picture Catalog of the First Batch of Precious and Compilation of Ancient Articles.