遗产价值的多样性及其当代保护实践的批判性思考被引量：18

On the Multi-values of Architectural Heritage and the Practice of Historic Preservation

下载PDF

导出

摘要关于遗产价值的多样性和矛盾性问题,西方学者已经提供了一系列颇有影响的理论研究成果。本文尝试以吸收李格尔、萧依和梅森这三位不同时代学者的相关理论,结合对当前我们关于遗产价值的认识特征与形成环境的分析,对上海近年来历史建筑保护的种种实践状况展开批判性的思考。 There have been quite significant arguments on the problem of multi-values in the historic preservation. By reading the related theories of Riegl, Choay and Mason, the author tries to come to a critical disccussion to the ideas and practices of the historic p.reservation in the city of Shanghai in recent years.

作者卢永毅

机构地区同济大学建筑与城市规划学院

出处《同济大学学报（社会科学版）》 CSSCI 北大核心 2009年第5期35-43,118,共10页 Journal of Tongji University:Social Science Edition

基金国家科技支撑计划重大项目编号2006BAJ03A07

关键词遗产保护多种价值西方理论上海实践 historic preservation multi-values western theories Shanghai practice

分类号 TU-80 [艺术—艺术设计]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献13

1卢永毅.历史保护与原真性的困惑[J].同济大学学报（社会科学版）,2006,17(5):24-29. 被引量：68
2罗小末.上海建筑风格与上海文化[M]//罗小未.上海建筑指南.上海:上海人民美术出版社,1996.
3Franqoise Chaoy: The Invention of the Historic. Monument[M]. translated by Lauren M. O'Connell. Cambridge University Press, 2001.
4李格尔.论文《对纪念物的现代崇拜:其特点与起源》(The Modern Cult of the Historic Monument,1903).
5李格尔.《对纪念物的现代崇拜:其特点与起源》,陈平著.《李格尔与艺术科学》,中国美术学院出版社,2002年,第324-325,328-332页.
6Francoise Chaoy: The Invention of the Historic Monument, translated by Lauren M. O'Connell, Cambridge University Press, 2001,139 - 141.
7Francoise Chaoy: The Invention of the Historic Monument, translated by Lauren M. O'Connell, pp. 142 - 143,144 - 148.
8Francoise Chaoy: Thelnvention of the Historic Monument, translated by Lauren M. O'Connell, p. 144.
9罗小未.《上海建筑风格与上海文化》,《上海建筑指南》,上海人民美术出版社,1996年.
10《“返老还童”造出假老上海-阮仪三昨批评新天地保护石库门是失败样本》,《新民晚报》,2008年8月23日.

二级参考文献7

1[1]Francoise Choay,The Invention of the Historic Monument,Translated by Lauren M.O'Connell,Cambridge University Press,2001,P.102.
2[2]John Ruskin,The Seven Lamps of Architecture,Dover Publications,Inc.New York,1989,pp.194～197.
3[1][4]Francoise Choay,The Invention of the Historic Monument,Translated by Lauren M.O'Connell,Cambridge University Press,2001,P.102,P.105.
4[2][3]Jukka Jokilehto,A History of Architectural Conservation,Butterworth-Heinemann,1999,P.180,P.151.
5[2][3][4]Jukka Jokilehto,A History of Architectural Conservation,Butterworth-Heinemann,1999,P.151.
6[1]Francoise Choay,The Invention of the Historic Monument,Translated by Lauren M.O'Connell,Cambridge University Press,2001,P.111.
7[2][3]Alois Riegl,Modern Cult of Monument:its character and origin (1907),引自 K.Michael Hays ed,Oppositions Reader,Princeton Architectural Press,1998,P621.