论科技学术论文创新性的初审评价

On editor's primary evaluation of academic paper's creativeness

分析学术论文的创新特色和3个创新属性,从5个方面提出了编辑初审评价学术论文创新性的方法:把握学科领域性和专业方向性,初步判断是否有创新;运用对比法,评价学术真实性;分析学术论文各组成部分之间的逻辑相关性,判断创新可信度;对照关键参考文献,追索研究起点;依据作者的创新性说明,查证核实创新。

Based on an analysis of the characteristics and three attributes of creativeness,this article proposes five measures of primarily evaluating academic paper＇s creativeness for editors as follows：to make an initial judgment according to the territoriality and directionality of the discipline;to have learning＇s authenticity appraised by contrast method in order to deter academic dishonorableness;to grasp the reliability of paper＇s creativeness via analyzing the logical relationship between body text and title,abstract,introduction,and conclusion as a whole;to clarify the origin of the research with the help of bibliography;to investigate and verify the novelty of the study in reference to author＇s explanations on creativeness.