话语讲述与叙述姿态:“十七年”文学的归属差异与分歧——从《新文艺大系》、《新文学大系》的小说篇目编选谈起

Difference and Divergence on the Classification of the "17 Years' Literature"

《中国新文艺大系》与《中国新文学大系》在"十七年文学"的小说篇目编选上,表现了编选者不同的精神背景对同一段文学的不同讲述,以及编选者所处的时代背景的规训,在"谁"的"十七年文学"这一问题上存在着归属的差异与分歧。我们应该以客观的目光去正视这段历史,靠近这段真实存在过的文学,最真实地还原这段文学的历史,从而给予"十七年文学"以更准确、更真实的文学史定位。

The approaches compilers of China＇s New Art and Literature Survey and China＇s New Literature Survey took to the title selection of the fiction section of the ＂17year＇s literature＂ reflect their differences of the compilers＇ spiritual and historical background. The compilers could not agree on who commands a dominant position in the 17years＇ literature. To accurately define this period, we should look at this period objectively and historically.