我国三种肝胆外科学术期刊学术水平与影响力比较分析

Comparative analysis of academic level and impact of three domestic learned periodicals of hepatobiliary surgery

目的进一步了解我国肝胆外科学术期刊的整体水平和影响力。方法采用文献计量学方法,依据2002-2008年版《中国学术期刊综合引证报告》(CAJCCR)的数据及《中国引文数据库》2001-2007年的数据,统计我国大陆出版的3种肝胆外科学术期刊(《中华肝胆外科杂志》、《肝胆外科杂志》、《肝胆胰外科杂志》)的载文量、影响因子(IF)、总被引频次、被引文章篇数、被引率、篇均被引频次、即年指标、基金论文比、h指数,并计算出各指标的平均值、h2/n、A指数、g指数等指标。结果前述3种肝胆外科学术期刊2001-2007年IF均值、被引频次均值分别为0.557和756.6,高于《CAJCCR》D辑(医药卫生类期刊)每刊平均值。经对IF、被引频次均值、总被引频次、篇均被引频次、被引率、即年指标、基金论文比、h指数、h2/n、A指数、g指数、高被引论文比等12种指标的排序,《中华肝胆外科杂志》12种指标均位居第一;《肝胆外科杂志》4种指标居第2名,8种指标居第3名;《肝胆胰外科杂志》9种指标居第2名,3种指标居第3名。结论我国3种肝胆外科学术期刊的学术水平和学术影响力逐年提高。

Objective To further understand the overall level and impact of the domestic learned periodicals of hepatobiliary surgery.Methods Based on the data of ＂Chinese Academic Journal Comprehensive Citation Report＂（CAJCCR） published in 2002-2008 and ＂Chinese Citation Database＂ from 2001 to 2007,statistics of three published journals of hepatobiliary surgery in mainland of China,including the volume of contained texts,impact factor（IF）,total cited frequency,number of cited articles,cited rate,cited frequency per article,immediacy index,ratio of fund papers and h index were gathered using bibliometrics method;and the average of each index,h2/n,A index,g index and so on were calculated.Results From 2001 to 2007,the IF mean value and cited frequency of three learned periodicals of hepatobiliary surgery were 0.557 and 756.6 respectively,higher than that of the average per issue of ＂CAJCCR＂ D series（journal of medicine and public health）.According to the arrange of order of 12 kinds of index,including IF,mean value of cited frequency,total cited frequency,cited frequency per article,cited rate,immediacy index,ratio of fund papers,h index,h2/n,A index,g index and rate of highly cited papers etc.,12 indexes of ＂Chinese Hepatobiliary Surgery Journal＂ were all in the first place;4 indexes of ＂Hepatobiliary Surgery Journal＂ were in the second place and 8 indexes of it in the third place,9 indexes of ＂Hepatopancreatobiliary Surgery Journal＂ in the second place and 3 indexes of it in the third place.Conclusion Aademic level and impact of three domestic learned periodicals of hepatobiliary surgery increase progressively year by year.