冯批失范疑窦频——冯其庸先生《瓜饭楼重校评批〈红楼梦〉》谬误辩难

On Feng Qiyong’s Annotations & Commentaries on A Dream of Red Mansions——An Analysis of Feng Qiyong’s Re-commentaries on A Dream of Red Mansions in My Residential Place Guofanlou

资深红学家冯其庸先生花数十年心血编纂一部长达160万字的巨著《瓜饭楼重校评批〈红楼梦〉》,且被吹嘘为"发前人所未发,为当代红学的最新成果","是一部可读性、欣赏性极强,且有极高收藏价值的关于《红楼梦》的传世佳本。"研读后始知此乃虚浮夸饰之词。仅从上卷前40回的评批中就凸现出包括常识性、知识性、思想性、学术性等方面的失范现象达14处之多。为减轻对广大读者和后学的贻误和不良影响,特逐条加以辩难匡正。

Feng Qiyong, a senior expert in studying A Dream of Red Mansions, spent several decades in compiling a book with 1.6 million words entitled Re-commentaries on A Dream of Red Mansions in My Residential Place Guofanlou. He boasts it of the latest research that no one has done before, with high readability and appreciation, and a masterpiece that is worth collecting and handing down for generations. However, it is not the case. In his annotations and commentaries on the first 40 chapters of A Dream of Red Mansions, up to 14 mistakes have been found, including the mistakes of common sense, knowledge, ideology and academic ideas, etc. To eliminate the negative effect on readers, each mistake is corrected accordingly in the paper.