专利有效性争议仲裁的双维度考察

A Double Latitude Explore into Arbitration in Patent Validity Disputes

近些年来,专利有效性争议的适裁性在理论上的合理性已得到学界众多学者的认可。然而,一项制度的确立不仅需要应然性的理论证明,还需要对现实操作层面中可能面临的困难作出具体的预计和全面的考量。此类争议本身的特殊性决定了其不可避免的涉及到对公共利益的潜在侵蚀,同时,还面临着与我国现有的行政、司法争议解决程序有效衔接与协调的难题。因此,我国在坚持此类争议具有适裁性方向的同时,还应正视其可能引发的问题,从理论与实践两方面准备好充分的应对策略和解决方案。

Recently,it has been accepted by many scholars that the disputes concerning the validity of patent should be related to arbitration.With the unique characteristics of patent,the assessment of patent validity inevitably involves the consideration of public interest.Therefore,its arbitration procedure must be coordinated with the other dispute means like judicial and administrative proceedings.However,the scholars＇ analysis is too abstract to solve the concrete problems.As a result,while adhering to the arbitrability of the patent validity disputes,we should attach more importance to the potential problems arising from it and make good preparation to solve them.