期刊文献+

图尔敏模型在当代法律论证中的应用 被引量:1

Application of Toulmin Model in Contemporary Legal Proof
下载PDF
导出
摘要 图尔敏的法律论证理论与他的一般论证理论水乳交融。图尔敏不仅是法律论证理论的开拓者,而且其法律论证理论对新兴的"人工智能和法律"研究领域产生了重大影响,尤其是图尔敏模型,不仅被扩展为刻画复杂法律论证的基本模型,而且也被诠释为包括法律解释过程的动态模型。 Toulmin' s legal proof theory is in perfect harmony with his general proof theory. Not only is Toulmin the legal proof theory earlier worker, but his legal proof theory has major impact on the emerging "the artificial intelligence and the law", particularly the Toulmin model, which is not only expanded into the fundamental model to portray complex legal proof, but also annotated to include the dynamic model of law interpreting process.
作者 杨宁芳
出处 《重庆理工大学学报(社会科学)》 CAS 2010年第11期8-12,共5页 Journal of Chongqing University of Technology(Social Science)
关键词 论坛 论证 法律论证 图尔敏模型 疑难案件 forum proof legal proof Toulmin model difficult case
  • 相关文献

参考文献12

  • 1杨宁芳.论图尔敏的法律论证理论[J].重庆理工大学学报(社会科学),2010,24(8):23-26. 被引量:4
  • 2杨宁芳.图尔敏的法律论证特性[J].重庆与世界,2010,27(11):18-20. 被引量:1
  • 3Eveline T. Feteris, Fundamentals of Legal Argumentation : A Survey of Theories on Justification of Judicial Decisions, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1999:47,190.
  • 4Toulmin S,Rieke R,Janik A. An Introduction to Reasoning[ M ]. [ S. l. ] : Macmillan, 1979:25 - 27.
  • 5焦宝乾.法律论证及其在法律方法体系中的地位[J].法制与社会发展,2008,14(3):127-137. 被引量:10
  • 6Olaf Tans, The Fluidity of Warrants : using the Toulmin model to analyse practical discourse, in David Hitchcock and Bart Verheij (eds.) ,Arguing on the Toulmin Model: new essays in argument analysis and evaluation, Springer, 2006:219 - 230.
  • 7Ronald P. Loui, A Citation-Based Reflection on Toulmin and Argument, in Argumentation, 2002, 16 ( 3 ) : 259 - 266.
  • 8武宏志,周建武,唐坚.非形式逻辑导论[M].北京:人民出版社.2009.
  • 9Henry Prakken, AI & Law, Logic and Argument Schemes, in Argumentation ,2005,19 ( 3 ) :303 - 320.
  • 10John Zeleznikow, Using Toulmin Argumentation to Support Dispute Settlement in Discretionary Domains, in David Hiteheoek and Bart Verheij (eds.), Arguing on the Toulmin Model :New Essays in Argument Analysis and Evaluation, Springer,2006, pp. 289 - 302.

二级参考文献46

  • 1舒国滢.从方法论看抽象法学理论的发展[J].浙江社会科学,2004(5):39-47. 被引量:51
  • 2郑永流.法律判断大小前提的建构及其方法[J].法学研究,2006,28(4):3-18. 被引量:59
  • 3张保生.法律推理中的法律理由和正当理由[J].法学研究,2006,28(6):80-88. 被引量:40
  • 4Toulmin S, Rieke R, Janik A. An Introduction to Reasoning[ M]. [S.l. ] :Macmillan,1979:204.
  • 5Toulmin S. The Uses of Argument [ M ]. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 1999:7,42 - 43,255.
  • 6Milos Jenicek , David L. Hitchcock. Evidence-Based Practice: Logic and Critical Thinking in Medicine[ M]. [ S. l. ] :AMA Press,2005:52.
  • 7Kathleen Freeman, Arthur M Farley. A Model of Argumentation and Its Application to Legal Reasoning [ J ]. Artificial Intelligence and Law, 1996,4:163 -197.
  • 8Henry Prakken , Giovannni Sartor. Logical Models of Legal Argumentation [ M ]. [ S. l. ] : Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1997 : 169.
  • 9[德]卡尔·拉伦茨 陈爱娥译.法学方法论[M].北京:商务印书馆,2003.200.
  • 10[德]罗伯特·阿列克西 舒国滢译.法律论证理论[M].北京:中国法制出版社,2002..

共引文献18

同被引文献21

  • 1阮松.西方的非形式逻辑运动与我国逻辑学的走向[J].南开学报(哲学社会科学版),1996(6):34-39. 被引量:17
  • 2陈剩勇,杜洁.互联网公共论坛与协商民主:现状、问题和对策[J].学术界,2005(5):35-47. 被引量:47
  • 3苏振华.公共协商是有效的吗-基于温岭市的案例与数据的实证研究[EB/OL].[2014-05-30].http://www.doe88.com/p-7856110139680.html.
  • 4McCoy M L, Scully P L. Deliberative dialogue to expand civic engagement: What kind of talk does democracy need? [J ]. National Civic Review, 2002, 91(2) : 117- 135.
  • 5瞻姆斯·博曼.公共协商:多元主义、复杂性与民主[M].黄相怀,译.北京:中央编译出版社,2006.
  • 6Toulmin S E. The Uses of Argument [ M ] . Cambridge England: Cambridge University .Press, 2003.
  • 7西方逻辑史[EB/OL].[2014-05-30].http://baike.baidu.corn/view/11072l1.htm.
  • 8McCroskey J C. Toulmin and the basic course[J]. SpeechTeacher, 1965, 14(2) : 91 - 100.
  • 9Anderson R L, Mortensen C D. Logic and marketplace argumentation[J]. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 1967, 53(2) 143- 151.
  • 10Burleson B R. A congnitive - developmental perspective on social reasoning processes[J] . Western Journal of Speech Communic - ation, 1981, 45(2) : 133- 147.

引证文献1

二级引证文献1

相关作者

内容加载中请稍等...

相关机构

内容加载中请稍等...

相关主题

内容加载中请稍等...

浏览历史

内容加载中请稍等...
;
使用帮助 返回顶部