聚众淫乱罪问题新探——由“马尧海换妻案”引发的思考

Assembled Licentious Activities,Guilty or Not guilty——Discussing for MaYaohai's Wife Swap Case

本文以南京马尧海等人"换偶"一案的审判结果以及学术界的争论为背景,论证聚众淫乱行为入罪的正当性和合理性。任何一种行为入罪必须满足法益侵害性、违反伦理性和惩罚必要性三个条件。聚众淫乱行为可以满足这三个条件,因此应当治罪。但是,由于社会的发展和人们观念的改变,我国立法中的聚众淫乱罪确有修改完善的必要。为此,本文建议将聚众淫乱罪设置为情节犯,以在维护秩序和保障人权方面达成平衡。

This thesis bases on the judgment of Ma Yaohai as the header of Wife Swap Case in Nanjing and the academic disputes of this judgment,talks about the legitimacy and rationality of the criminalization of assembled licentious activities.If any criminalization of an activity meet three conditions：the nature of violation to legal interest,the nature of against ethicality and the nature of the necessity of penalty,it can be processed as committing a crime,so assembled licentious activities are.However,as the development of society and the changing of people＇s ideas,perfecting the legislation of assembled licentious activities is necessary.Consequently,in this thesis,the writer suggests considering assembled licentious activities as circumstance crime,for keeping the balance of maintaining law and order and protecting human rights.