论定罪与量刑的关系模式

Relation Models of Conviction and Sentencing Criterion

定罪与量刑的关系模式是我国量刑程序改革理论上的争点与实践中的难点。探寻一种适合我国国情的定罪与量刑关系模式,对推动我国量刑程序改革的深入进行有着非常重大的意义。对于被告人认罪案件,各界普遍认为应适用相对独立的量刑程序,目前专家学者们的分歧在于对被告人不认罪的案件应适用相对独立的量刑程序还是独立的量刑程序。各地方法院量刑程序改革试点的实践证明,对于被告人不认罪案件的审理,独立的量刑程序更具科学性与合理性。

The relation model of conviction and sentencing criterion is a hot argument theoretically and a difficulty practically for Chinese reform on sentencing criterion.A reasonable relation model of conviction and sentencing criterion is of great significance for the further reform.Concerning the case of the peccavi of the accused,a relative independent sentencing procedure is agreed generally,while the major disagreement is whether relative independent procedure or totally independent procedure should be applied in the case of the plea of not guilty of the accused.It is proved in practice,that the dependent procedure is more scientific and reasonable in such case.