非法拘禁中的暴力致死

Discussion on the Violent Death in Illegal Detention

在一起因索债而致受害人死亡的刑事案件中,有人认为被告构成绑架罪,有人认为属于非法拘禁,还有人认为应按故意杀人惩处。到底该如何认定呢?

In a criminal case, the victim was died because of demanding payment of a debt. Some people think the defendants committed kidnapping, some say they were guilty of illegal detention, and still others suggest they should be considered intentional homicide. Then how to identify it in the end？