摘要
我国目前的刑事司法实践完全没有深深陷入法律形式主义的泥坑,因而需要采用实质解释论加以拯救,而恰恰是深深陷入了法律实质主义的泥坑,由此逾越了罪刑法定原则的樊篱,因而需要引入形式解释论加以纠正。在某种意义上,形式解释论与实质解释论之争不仅是构成要件论之争,甚至是刑法机能论之争、刑法观之争。在我国当下社会中,法治规则意识尚未完全建立。在这种前法治时代,我国应该大力弘扬规则功利主义。
At the present stage, criminal judicial practice is not in the morass of legal formalism and need to be saved by interpretation on substance, but on the contrary, in the morass of legal substantialism, goes beyond the principle of crime and punishment by law, and need to be saved by interpretation on form. It can be seen that the controversial between interpretation on form and interpretation on substance is not a debate on composing factors of crime, but rather the debate on the function and view of criminal law. China is still in the times of pre - rule of law, it is necessary to enhance normative utilitarianism.
出处
《法制与社会发展》
CSSCI
北大核心
2011年第2期3-9,共7页
Law and Social Development
关键词
法律形式主义
法律实质主义
形式解释论
实质解释论
规则功利主义
legal formalism
legal substantialism
interpretation on form
interpretation on substance
normative utilitarianism
