法官等级制度的困境与出路初探

Discussion of the Plights and Outlets of the Judge Rating System

法官"无视"法官等级的现象在法院中普遍存在,法官等级制度不断被边缘化。这主要是由于制度不合理和实施受体制限制造成的。虽然法官等级制度面临重重困难,但在建立独立的法官序列、形成有效的现代司法管理体系和维护审判独立和司法公正方面,有独特的存在价值。因此,坚持正确的理念和方向,进行制度的完善,是法官等级制度走出困境的出路所在。

The phenomenon is common that the grades of judges is ignored by the judges in courts of law. Because of irrational system and restricted implementation in reality,the judge rating system is constantly marginalized,Although it faces double troubles,the judge rating system has a unique existence value to build an independent judge sequence,to set up effectively modern judicial administration system,to maintain trial independence and judicial fairness.Therefore,adopting the correct concept and direction to perfect the judge rating system is a way to get out of the difficulty.