唐时诸王冰析疑

Clearing the doubts of all Wang Bing in the Tang dynasty

依据《四库提要辨证》中提供的线索对唐时诸王冰作进一步探讨。余嘉锡书中所言韦抗举荐之王冰与宇文融举荐者可能是一人 ,二者与《素问》的注者在时间上均相重合。而且 ,《列女传》中记载的王琳之子王冰与韦抗、宇文融举荐之王冰、及《素问》注者在时间上也相重合 ,也存在着是一人的可能。而《郎官石柱题名》之王冰则不可考。对于称王者 ,或如诸家所言 ,乃附会杜甫诗而改之 ,其为《素问》

The problem is probed on the clues provided by Si ku ti yao bian zheng(Analysis on Summary of Books in Four Parts).It is claimed that the Wang bing(NFDCA)recommended by Wei Kang and that recommended by Yuwen Rong in Yu Jiaxi's work refer to the same person,both are identical to the time of the author of Su wen.Further,the time of the above 2Wang Bing(s)and the Wang Bing recorded in lie nu zhuan(Biongraphies of chaste women)as the son of Wang Lin,are also overlapped with the time of the author of Su wen.It is possible that they are the same person.However,the details of the Wang Bing mentioned in Lang guan shi zhu ti ming(inscription for Lang guan Stone Pillar)is unknown.Again,it is unlikely that the Wang Bing()is the author of Su wen and cna be only a farfetched analogies drawn after Su Fu's poet.