《唐百家诗选》著作权争议的祛蔽与坐实——《唐百家诗选》的编选者“非为王安石而是宋敏求”考辨

On the Underlying of the Copyright of Selected Poems of Tang——An Research on the Compiler of Selected Poems of Tang "Not Wang Anshi but Song Minqiu"

《唐百家诗选》究竟是王安石还是宋敏求编选的,一直以来众说纷纭,而把它的著作权归为王安石基本上已成为"定论"和主流观点。文章以新发现的一则材料,即与宋敏求同称"熙宁三舍人"的苏颂元丰二年(1079)给宋敏求写的一篇《龙图阁直学士修国史宋公神道碑》为直接依据,对捆绑在这种著作权争议问题上的各种宋代证据一一剖析,找出其中隐含着的诸多矛盾,企图揭示从中推导出来的事实真相,把这个选本的著作权重新还给宋敏求。

＂Selected Poems of Tang＂,whether it is compiled by Song Minqiu or Wang Anshi,the controversy has always been upheld from different opinions,but the copyright on it as Wang has basically become a ＂conclusion＂ and the mainstream.This paper,regarding a newly discovered material,that is,an article ＂Lung To Court Bachelor straight national history Songgong Shinto monument repair ＂ in Yuanfeng second years（1079） written to Song Minqiu by Su Song who is called ＂Xining three Scheeren＂ with Song Minqiu,as the direct basis,gives an analysis of various evidences in Song dynasty bundled in this issue of the copyright dispute,identifies many implied contradictions,attempts to reveal the derived truth,and rebacks the copyright of this election to Song Minqiu.