论慈利楚简的性质

On the Nature of Cili Chu Bamboo Slips

慈利楚简整理者将简文内容分为两类:一是传世文献典籍可资对勘的,如《国语.吴语》和《逸周书.大武》;一是《管子》、《宁越子》等书的佚文或古佚书。有的学者不同意整理者的意见,认为这批楚简极有可能为铎椒所作的《铎氏微》。其实从简文及《铎氏微》文体的比较来看,整理者的观点更切合简文实际。慈利楚简对于理解《国语》的编纂来说提供重要的材料,但是《国语》和《逸周书》并非像整理者所言可能是同一部书。

The collators of Cili Chu Bamboo Slips categorized the content into two： one is ancient records such as ＂Wuyu in Guoyu＂ and ＂Dawu in Yi Zhou Shu＂;tow is ancient lost articles or books such as ＂Guan Zi＂（＂the Book of Master Guan＂） and ＂Ning Yue Zi＂.Some scholars argue that Cili Chu Bamboo slips might be from ＂Duo＇s Wei＂ by Duo Jiao.This paper insists that collators＇ idea is more practical for bamboo slips.