我国共犯限制从属性之提倡

The Advocation of the Restrictions on Dependency of Accomplice

目前在我国关于教唆犯争论的观点还是集中在从属性与二重性之争上,还鲜有学者对我国的共犯的从属性的程度进行系统的研究。事实上,我国的从属性程度采取的是极端从属性,但是我国通说存在诸多问题与不合理之处,并为笔者所不取。而限制从属性说的德日刑法中的通说,该理论具有颇多优点,而且也能切合我国的司法实际。如果我国一改通说采用限制从属性说,在解释论上也并不存在障碍。而且倡导限制从属性说对于发展共犯理论具有极其重要的理论价值。

At present the debate about instigators focuses on the issue of the dependency and duality battle in China,few scholars make a systemic research on the extent of dependency of accomplice.In fact,China takes extreme dependency,but there are some problems and shortcomings existing in current general law rules,which somhow the writer disagrees with.The theory＂restrictions on dependency＂ derived from the criminal laws of Germany and Japan has its advantages and somehow suits for Chinese judicial practice as well.If it is taken,on one hand there does not exist obstacles in explaining its theory,on the other advocating ＂restrictions on dependency＂ has an important theoretical value in developing accomplice theory.