性自主权、道德与法律干预——以“南京换偶案”为例

Autonomy in Sex,Moral & Legal Interference——Based on the Spouse Exchanging Case in Naijing

"换偶案"作为一个聚讼纷争的特殊案例,在道德、价值多元化的时代,引发了人们对"换偶"的权利,道德性及合法性的多向度的思考。在将"换偶"纳入性自主权的思考维度中,性的自治自决也必须与责任担当与人性尊严相协调;在道德、法律的聚光灯下,即使是坚守自由主义的中立原则,对"换偶"之类的性行为方式,也只是主张一定的道德宽容而非道德虚无。当然,法律在有限度涉入这一高度争议的性领域时,应有坚实的干预理由并保持适度的界限。

As a hotly debated suit,the case of Spouse-Exchanging in Nanjing has aroused people＇s meditation on the right,morality and legality of exchanging spouses in an era of moral and value pluralism.Even it could be deemed as a kind of autonomy in sex to ＂exchange spouses＂,it must be coordinated with undertaking of liabilities and respect for human nature.In the light of moral and law,even those who hold tightly the neutral principle of freedom claim that sexual behaviors like spouse-exchanging should be morally tolerated only to a certain extent rather than accepted regardless of morality at all.Of course,limited legal interference in this highly controversial area should be well justified and implemented within moderate boundaries.