对《学者的社会责任与马克思主义基本立场》一文的看法——与何怀远先生商榷

Views on the article "Scholars' Social Responsibility and Basic Positions of Marxism"-Discussion with Mr.He Huaiyuan

何怀远先生的文章《学者的社会责任与马克思主义基本立场》存在值得商榷之处:一是有些地方让读者难于看懂;二是有些论证文不对题;三是作为国家级重点课题,在学术规范上尚有欠缺;四是的文章中的一些提法和观点,不但与马克思主义的立场和观点有距离,而且相悖于基本的社会认知和良知。本文从四个方面提出了看法:一是对"我们需要什么样的忧患意识?"的商榷;二是对"我们需要什么样的‘强国梦’"的商榷;三是对"中国需要和美国建立什么样的关系?"的商榷;四是对"我们需要什么样的爱国主义"的商榷。

Some pointes of Mr.He Huaiyuan's article 'Scholars' Social Responsibility and Basic Position of Marxism' are under discussion:firstly,some pointes in the article is obscure to the readers;Secondly,some arguments don't accord with the theme;thirdly,as a national level study,the article is deficient in academic norms;Fourthly,some arguments and ideas are not only contrary to the Marxist stand and views,but also violate basic social cognition and conscience.This paper would like to discuss with Mr.He Huaiyuan's article on four issues:'What kind of awareness of unexpected we need';'What kind of power we dream of';'What kind of Sino-US relationship we need' and 'What kind of patriotism we need'.