国内大学排行指标体系设置理念的比较

A Comparative Study of Index System's Setting Idea of China University Rankings

指标体系的设置理念是大学排行的灵魂,在思想层面上对大学排行起决定性作用,并最终影响到排行的结果。以民间性、综合性和连续性为选取原则,以广东管理科学研究院武书连主持的《中国大学评价》、网大有限公司推出的《中国大学排行榜》、中国校友会网发布的《中国大学排行榜》、武汉大学中国科学评价研究中心推出的《中国高校竞争力评价》为研究对象,对目前国内广为流行的四大民间大学排行榜指标体系设置理念进行比较,分析其异同,以期对大学的民间评价提供有益借鉴。

Index system's setting idea is the soul of the university's rankings,which plays a guiding role in the operation of ranking from the ideological aspect,and ultimately affects the ranking result.On the basis of nongovernmental,comprehensiveness,and consecutiveness principle,this paper chooses as the research subjects Evaluation of Chinese Universities by WU Shulian from Guangdong Management Science Research Institute,Chinese Universities Rankings by NetBig,Chinese Universities Rankings by CUAA and Chinese Universities Competitiveness Evaluation by Research Center of Chinese Science Evaluation of Wuhan Univesrity,and compares index system's setting ideas among them,which may provide reference for the university evaluation.