秦始皇生父之谜——求教于王立群先生

Mystery of Qin Shi Huang's Own Father:a Discussion with Mr.Wang Liqun

学术界对秦始皇生父问题,各抒己见,而王立群先生认为秦始皇生父不是吕不韦而是异人。但作者经过分析研究吕不韦的从政经历,认为吕不韦是秦始皇之生父,而异人为秦始皇之养父,其理由有五:一是从吕不韦向华阳夫人进献异人,向太后进献嫪毐来看,吕不韦向异人进献赵姬也是顺理成章的事实;二是从吕不韦与异人当时所处的处境分析,作为弱者异人不可能夺强者吕不韦的爱妾;三是"大期"而生,未必都是智障儿,不能用现在的医学水平来分析研究历史事件;四是因为异人不知道赵姬有身孕,而赵姬又隐瞒不说,所以异人误认为秦始皇为自己亲生儿子,出生于赵地,取名赵正,理所当然;五是吕不韦"饮酖而死",并非"恐诛",而是深受儒家思想影响的吕不韦因亲生儿子秦始皇对他不恭而断绝父子关系,所以羞耻而"饮酖"自尽。

There are divergent opinions about Qin Shi Huang＇s own father.Mr.Wang Liqun proposed that Qin Shi Huang＇s own father is Yi Ren but not Lu Buwei.The author thinks that Lu Buwei is Qin Shi Huang＇s own father,while Yi Ren is his foster father.Arguments for his proposition are listed in the paper.