诗性正义的实现——从刑法学方法论角度探讨

The Realization of Poetic Justice from the Prospect of Criminal Methodology

文学作品与刑法学研究的逻辑起点和适用终端均为社会中的人,二者所要面对的问题具有同源性,均为社会制度与人类意志、行为之间无穷尽的矛盾和冲突。面对多样态的矛盾和冲突,刑法以抽象性原则、强制性规范予以调整,而文学却以多元的视角、敏锐的触觉深刻再现了矛盾和冲突的萌芽、发展和激化,着力于探索其形成过程背后深刻的社会背景和历史根源——二者于方法论层面存在者隐性融合和交叉。文学可以将刑事古典学派、规范学派和社会学派的观点有机融合,拓展刑法学研究视野,将刑法学研究进一步推向深层次、广维度。

Literature and criminal law researches share the starting point and terminal application,which are people in society.The problems tackled by the two issues are homologous,dealing with the endless contradictions and conflicts between the social system and the human will and acts.Criminal law regulates the contradictions and conflicts through abstract principles and peremptory norms,while literature reproduces the rudiment,development and intensification of the contradictions and conflicts with diverse perspectives and sensitivity in an effort to explore the profound social background and historical roots of their formation.Literature and criminal law integrate each other in methodology.Literature can integrate the points of view of criminal classical school,norm school and sociology school,enhancing the criminal research in wider and deeper dimension.