《春秋繁露》五行诸篇真伪考

Authenticity of the five elements in Spring and Autumn Annals(Chunqiu Fanlu)

对于《春秋繁露》五行诸篇是否为董仲舒所著,台湾和海外学者早有怀疑并取得了一定的研究成果。然而,大陆学者至今没有关注这个问题。《春秋繁露》五行诸篇的后七篇有大量文字和《汉书.五行志》、《说苑》相似,并且只用《尚书》而非《春秋》说灾异,说明这七篇不是董仲舒而是刘向的作品。另外两篇则为董仲舒的作品。

Suspicion arises in Taiwan and other overseas regions on the authencity of the five elements in Spring and Autumn Annals（Chunqiu Fanlu） concerning the authorship. It is argued that the final seven chapters are identical with Hanshu Five Elements ,and Analects, Books and Spring and Autumn cannot be convincing enough to prove the authorship. The conclusion is the author of the seven chapters of the five elements in Spring and Autumn Annals（Chunqiu Fanlu） is Liu Xiang, the two remaining chapters are by Dong Zhongshu.