李某凯强奸案的争议与分析——威胁下帮助行为的认定

Controversy and analysis of the rape of Li Moukai——Identification of helping behavior under the threat

温州的一起强奸案件,由于司机不具有与加害人共同的犯罪故意,也即可归责的主观罪过,因此不构成共同犯罪,检察院和法院对该司机从犯(胁从犯)的定性是不恰当的。但是该司机的行为属于避险过当;也有可能构成不纯正不作为犯,所以应承担一定的刑事责任。从这个角度来说,检察院和法院以强奸罪对该司机进行定罪量刑又是合理的。

In a rape case in Wenzhou, because the driver does not have a common criminal intent with the perpetrators,or the subjective guilt can be attributable to,which do not constitute the crime,prosecutors and courts＇ characterization of the driver accomplice （coerced） is not appropriate.However,the driver＇s act is in an excessive hedge;may also constitute impure sin of omission,so he should bear some responsibility.From this perspective,prosecutors and courts＇ sentencing of rape for the driver is reasonable.