论刑事诉讼中的“合作式”司法模式

On the "Cooperative Justice Mode in Criminal Actions

在司法实践中法院因为被害人与被告人协商达成赔偿协议而对某些被告人予以从轻判处,甚至于在死刑事案件中舆论不时进行声讨的拿钱买命说,这些现象背后是不是能找到合理的理论支撑?在多元纠纷解决的潮流下,司法把刑事案件中被害人亲属与被告人亲属达成的赔偿协议作为量刑情节,在传统对抗模式之外,开辟了一条私力合作之路,这标志着刑事诉讼二元模式即传统"对抗式"司法模式与"合作式"司法模式的确立。

As a criminal judge,the author has a puzzle in his judicial practice a： could we find a theory to explain the following phenomena reasonably？-The defendants were given lighter punishment in the condition that the victims and the defendants reached a compensating agreement,even on some capital cases the public media reported as ＂buying life by money＂,and so on.The justice takes the compensating agreement,reached by the relatives of the victims and that of the defendants,as the circumstances of sentencing,which opened a way of private cooperation.And this is the mark of the binary pattern of Criminal Action,the ＂adversary＂ justice and the ＂cooperative＂ justice.