医生利用处方权收回扣的刑事责任刍议

Discussion on Criminal Responsibility of Doctors' Accepting Rebates by Using Prescription Right

处方权是执业医师的法定权利,不具有公权力的性质。医生利用处方权收取回扣对医院药品管理不会产生决定性作用,如果将这种违背医学职业伦理,违反《执业医师法》和《药品管理法》的行为上升到刑事法律责任,既不符合犯罪的构成要件,同时也违背了刑罚谦抑原则。

Prescription right,a legal right of licensed physicians,does not have the nature of public authority.The fact that doctors use prescription right to accept rebates does not play a decisive role in hospital drug management.So it is inconsistent with the constituent elements of crime and the restraining principle of penalty to rise these behaviors of violating professional ethics of physicians,Practicing Physicians Law and Drug Administration Law to criminal legal liability.