新见《天一阁书目》摘抄本校读记

COLLATABLE NOTES ON THE EXTRACT VERSION OF THE NEWLY FOUND TIANYI PAVILION CATALOGUE

天津图书馆从清管延芬《待清书屋杂抄再续编》一书中发现的数页抄自明范大冲编制的《天一阁书目》资料，为研究天一阁提供了新的宝贵材料．但经与三种有代表性的天一阁书目的核对，管氏摘抄本只占康熙间抄本所录书目的百分之二、三，不能代表范编书目而称之为“现存最早”的天一阁藏书目录．而刘尚恒先生对范编书目的考证文章则一误将黄宗羲字“太冲”与“大冲”张冠李戴；二误范钦的生卒年。

Pages of Tianyi Pavilion Catalogue (edited and published by Fan Dachong, Ming Dynasty)were discovered in ThanjingLibrary in the book Miscellanies of the Dai Qing Study. Volume Three (Guan Tingfen,Qing Dynasty). The finding has provided material for the research of the Tianyi Pavilion library. However, the collation of this and otherrepresentative catalogues proves that Guan's record only contains two to three precent of the book titles recorded in otherworks during the Kangxi years (1662-1722) of the Qing Dynasty and that it cannot be ranked as 'the earliest existing'catalogue of the Tianyi Pavilion Library collection The collation also shows that Mr. Liu Shangheng, in his article on Fan's cataiogue,mixed up Huang Zongxi's bandwriting Taichong'with 'Dachong' and marked Fan'sbirth and death years wrongly.