“市场的逻辑”的逻辑——与张维迎教授商榷

The Logic of "Market Logic"-A Discussion with Professor Zhang Weiying

自由市场主义囿限于固有的价值定位,以直线式逻辑演绎唱衰中国社会现实蕴涵,遮蔽市场经济的深刻社会内含和复杂内在结构,超逻辑建构市场的逻辑,非理性迷信市场的理性,不是制作一个更适合现实世界的模式,而是让现实世界更适合它的模式,为此不惜借助于形而上的工具逻辑伪证自由市场万能以证伪公有制市场经济命题。超越其狭隘视阈、价值偏见和思维定式,赋予市场经济既有的时序空间依托,将其置于社会发展一般趋势坐标辩证地思考,中国市场经济典型化运行背后透射出非典型性的鲜明制度特质,30年改革实践是对社会主义市场经济命题的证实而非证伪。

Through analyzing the core of the 'Market Logic,' we can find that because of limitations of its value related position,the free-market doctrine ignores the social reality with a linear logical deduction,obscures the profound social meaning and the complex internal structure of market economy,and constructs the logic of the market beyond logic.It irrationally believes in the reasoning of the market.Without care to create a more realistic model appropriate to the real world,it instead alters reality to fits its model,and proves that the free market is omnipotent and public ownership market economy is impossible even with resot to the instrumental logticl of metaphysics.Beyond its narrow view,value bias and stereotypical way of thinking,we shoudl look at market economy historically and dialectically,and we will find that Chinese market economy shows prominent non-typical systematic features,and that thirty years of reform constitutes the proof,rather than the anti-proof of the position of socialist market economy.