知识产权案件司法鉴定程序之探讨

Analyzing the Forensic Appraisal Procedure in Intellectual Property Cases

在知识产权案件的审理中,知识产权司法鉴定扮演着越来越重要的角色,特别是涉及争议知识产权事项的鉴定已成为案件定性的关键性证据。鉴定启动程序应当从司法鉴定特性出发,对鉴定实施中的法律与事实事项作出初步界分,以程序公正来架构"鉴定人、专家陪审员和专家辅助人"的审判程式,同时可以附之知识产权技术顾问,以此来维护和保障司法的实体公正。

In the trial of intellectual property cases,forensic appriasal has played an increasingly important role.The appraisal of items related to the controversial intellectual property rights has particularly become the critical evidence for deciding a case.The appraisal procedure should be initiated with a neutral standpoint from a forensic science institution and a preliminary distinction between legal matters and fact matters should be made.Due process can be established by the trial procedure of appraisers,expert juror and expert assessor,with the assistance of IPR advisors,to maintain and safeguard judicial substantive justice.