康德哲学思想佐证生态女性主义质疑

Query on Kant's Philosophy as a Proof to Eco-feminism

以凡.普罗姆伍德对二元论特征的描述为参照,考察了威尔逊对康德的评价。威尔逊认为,康德不是一位二元论者。可通过细致分析后可以发现,康德思想中至少体现了人类/自然、人类/动物以及文化/自然这三组对立,应该是一位二元论者。康德的哲学思想与生态女性主义的目标相去甚远,因为生态女性主义旨在揭露并瓦解二元对立,以康德思想佐证生态女性主义的做法应该属于对经典哲学的滥用。

Taking Val.Plumwood＇s description of the features of dualism as a reference,this paper evaluates the claims of Holly L.Wilson,who argues that Kant is not a dualist.After careful analysis,we think Kant at least maintains dualism between humans/nature,humans/animals,and humans/culture.As such,Kant＇s philosophy is antithetical to the aims of eco-feminism,which seeks to expose and dismantle such dualistic thinking.Trying to prove the claims of eco-feminism is no doubt a kind of abuse of philosophical canon.