医疗纠纷可仲裁性之法律思考

Legal considerations for the arbitrability of medical disputes

无论是学术界还是实务界在研究、探索通过仲裁处理医疗纠纷的过程中,都要依据我国法律思考医疗纠纷的可仲裁性问题。医疗纠纷的可仲裁性不仅决定了仲裁协议是否具有法律效力,而且关系到仲裁裁决会被国内法院撤销或者不被外国法院承认和执行,最终导致仲裁无效。笔者认为,根据我国仲裁法的规定,营利性医疗机构发生的医疗服务合同纠纷具有可仲裁性,除此之外的医疗纠纷则不具有。

The process of researching and exploring medical dispute resolutions through arbitration will need to be based on china＇s legal framework for the arbitrability of medical disputes in both academic and industry settings, the arbitrability of medical disputes not only determines the legal impacts of arbitration, but also concerns whether the arbitration would be withdrawn by domestic courts or accepted and executed by international courts, potentially resulting in ultimate invalidation of the arbitration, the author opines that based on the arbitration law of china, arbitrability only exists in medical service contract disputes occurred at for-profit institutions, all other medical disputes do not have arbitrability.