论物的担保范围内保证责任绝对豁免原则的实际废除

On the Actual Repeal of the Principle of Guarantees Absolute Immunity in the Scope of Guaranty

《中华人民共和国担保法》第28条实际上确立了一个"物的担保范围内保证责任绝对豁免原则",该条所确立的法律原则与《担保法》的立法精神实际形成了尖锐的矛盾冲突。最高人民法院关于《担保法》的司法解释第38条对该条的适用进行了初步限制,但还不尽完善。《中华人民共和国物权法》做出了与《担保法》第28条明显不同的规定,限制了该条的适用,更好地保护了债权人的合法权益。

The article 28 of the Guarantee Law of the People＇ s Republic of China in tact establishes responsibility to ensure that a range of property for the security principle of absolute immunity, the legal principles establish in that section and the legislative spirit of the security law the actual formation of a sharp conflicts. The Supreme People＇ s Court judicial interpretation of Article 38 on security application of the article conducted a preliminary restriction, but not perfect. Property Law of the People＇ s Republic of China has made a significantly different provisions from section 28 of the security law, limiting the application of the article, and better protect the legitimate rights and interests of the creditors.