“互著”、“别裁”起源时间考辨——读王重民先生《校雠通义通解》

The Origins of “Exchange Indexing” and “Reindexing”——With a Study of Wang Chongmin’s Jiao Chou Tong Yi Tong Jie

指出关于"互著"、"别裁"这两种文献著录方法的起源问题,历来就有诸多分歧。梳理学界现存的种种观点,尤其是剖析王重民先生在《校雠通义通解》中的归纳与分析,考辨"互著"、"别裁"产生的历史背景,并指出两者起源于刘歆的观点是不容置疑的。

In regard to the origins of two bibliographic methods ＂exchange indexing＂ and ＂＂ reindexing＇＂, there always exists many bifurcations. This paper intends to tease out the opinions existent in the academic circles, put special emphasis on anatomizing the inductions and analysis of Wang Chongmin in his book Jiao Chou Tong Yi Tong Jie, check and discern the historical context in which ＂exchange indexing＂ and ＂reindexing＂ came into being, and indicate the viewpoint that ＂exchange indexing＂ and ＂reindexing＂ originate from Lin Xin is unassailable.