医学院校教师绩效考核中的学术论文评价

Assessment of research papers in medical university staff evaluation

教师的工作绩效考核是医学院校教学管理的主要机制之一。学术论文产出数量作为一个直接反映医学院校教师工作绩效的指标,在绩效考核中起到了十分重要的作用,而论文影响力作为一个间接指标,同样是绩效考核中重要的指标之一。本文介绍了当前对学术论文进行评价时常用的一些指标,并分析了各个指标的作用和局限性,认为以学术论文评价为基础的医学院校教师工作绩效评价,应将期刊评价与同行评议相结合,定性评价与定量评价相结合,以建立更加客观、公正的绩效评价体系。

Medical university staff evaluation is a substantial branch of education administration for medical university. Output number of research papers as a direct index reflecting the achievements in academic research, plays an important role in academic research evaluation. Another index, influence of the research paper, is an indirect index for academic research evaluation. This paper mainly introduced some commonly used indexes in evaluation of academic research papers currently, and analyzed the applicability and limitation of each index. The author regards that academic research evaluation in education administration, which is mainly based on evaluation of academic research papers, should combine the evaluation of journals where the papers are published with peer review of the papers, and integrate qualitative evaluation with quantitative evaluation, for the purpose of setting up an objective academic research evaluation system for medical university staff.