全国高职高专医学学报质量调查及其提高对策

THE QUALITY SURVEYS ON THE JOURNALS OF NATIONAL VOCATIONAL MEDICAL COLLEGES AND THE COPING STRATEGIES

目的探讨高职高专医学学报的质量现状及其影响因素,为办好学报提供依据。方法随机抽取9所医学高等专科学校、11所本科医学院校2009至2011年出版的学报,各抽取1期,对其所刊文章的学术质量进行分析。结果 9期专科学校学报共发表文章278篇,期均(30.89±15.65)篇;11所医学本科院校学报共发表文章463篇,期均(42.09±10.34)篇。专科学报所载本校文章占39.93%,立项课题占11.51%;本科学报所载本校文章占24.19%,立项课题占32.18%;专科学报发表的本校文章比例高于本科学报(χ2=20.45,P<0.01),而本科学报发表的立项课题所占比例高于专科学报(χ2=40.21,P<0.01)。专科学报所载文章以临床疗效研究及教学研究为主,分别占31.29%及22.30%;本科学报以基础研究及临床疗效研究为主,分别占36.07%和28.29%。根据Jadad量表进行评分显示两类学报发表的90篇临床疗效随机对照研究的文章中没有1篇属于高质量研究。结论高职高专医学学报所刊文章的质量急需提高。

Objective To explore the current quality situation of the academic journals of national vocational medical colleges and the relevant influencing factors.Methods One issue from each of the journals of 9 vocational medical colleges and 11 medical colleges published from 2009 to 2011 was randomly selected to analyze the quality of its academic articles.Results There were 278 articles in all the 9 issues of the vocational medical college journals,with the average of（30.89±15.65）articles in each issue,and there were 463 articles in all the 11 issues of the medical college journals,with the average of（42.09±10.34）articles in each issue.39.93% of the articles from the vocational medical college journals were written by the teachers from the colleges where the journal was managed and 11.51% of them were based on research projects,while 24.19% of the articles from the medical college journals were written by the teachers from the colleges where the journal was managed and 32.18% of them were based on research projects.Compared with medical colleges,vocational medical colleges had more articles written by their own teachers（χ2=20.45,P〈0.01）,but less articles were based on research projects（χ2=40.21,P〈0.01）.The articles on therapeutic effect research and teaching research accounted for 31.29% and 22.30% of all the articles from the vocational medical college journals respectively,while the articles on basic medical research and therapeutic effect research accounted for 36.07% and 28.29% of all the articles from the vocational medical college journals respectively.None of the articles on therapeutic effect research from both the two kinds of journal belonged to high-quality research articles according to the Jadad measuring scale.Conclusion The quality of the articles from vocational medical college journal are in badly need of promotion.