批评的“恶”与“善”——“呜呼苏梅”公案与文章署名问题的论争

the "Evil" and "Good" in Criticism——Controversy Between "Alas Samui Detective" and the Article Authorship

"呜呼苏梅"公案与文章署名问题的论争是1920年代影响非常大的两桩有关学术讨论与批评的案例,但两起论争的结局则截然不同:一个由于人身攻击而引起整个新文化界的关注,一个则始终在学理的范畴内进行讨论,并和平收场。这相互关联的两起论争分别彰显了批评的"恶"与"善",也对后世的学术批评有着非常强的启示意义。

＂Alas Samui detective＂ and articles signed debates are two very large impact in the 1920s for academic discussion and criticism case, but the outcome of two cases of controversy was different. This interrelated two has a very strong significance from the controversy highlights the criticism of the ＂evil＂ and ＂good＂, but also has great significance on academic criticism to future generations.