《西京杂记》伪托刘歆作补论二则

Supplementary Discussion on XiJingZaJi's Author

关于《西京杂记》的作者主要有两种观点:其一,为刘歆所撰,葛洪所编集;其二,葛洪所编集,并托名于刘歆。文章赞同第二种观点,对之作了补论:一、葛洪《西京杂记跋》于理不通、疑点重重,不可作为论证《西京杂记》为刘歆撰的依据;二、"辨《尔雅》"条与刘歆的小学观相矛盾,也说明《西京杂记》当为托名于刘歆之所撰。

There are two kind of views about the author of XiJing ZaJi （《西京杂记》 ）, one is that the author is Liu Xin（刘歆）, and the another is that the author is Ge Hong（葛洪）. The article sup- ports the latter and gives two supplementary discussions.