医学论文退修的必要性——《中华微生物学和免疫学杂志》从编有感

Necessity of revision of medical papers:experience of editors working for Chinese Journal of Microbiology and Immunology

通过对《中华微生物学和免疫学杂志》部分稿件退修情况的统计分析,论述科技期刊文稿退修的必要性,即:退修是联系审稿专家、编辑和作者三者的桥梁;可提高论文的学术价值;使论文在格式上更规范;提高作者写作水平,储备优质作者资源;提升编辑的业务素质,培养编辑的审稿能力。认为退修时应注意以下问题:重视政治问题;切忌照本宣科;叙述明确,主次分明;尊重作者,体现修养;注明修回日期。

The necessity of revision of medical papers is discussed through statistics of paper revision. Paper revision is an important procedure that links reviewers, editors and authors. It can improve the academic value of papers, standardize paper writing, reserve elite author resources and cultivate young editors. More attention should be paid to such aspects： political issues must be considered seriously, reviewers＇ comments should not be repeated much, editors＇ presentation should be explicit, authors should be respected, and the exact date of authors＇ submission of revised manuscripts should be recorded.