融贯论、道德实在与法律——一个基于内在实在主义的整合被引量：2

Theory of Coherence,Moral Realism and Law An Integration Attempt Based on Internal Realism

导出

摘要不同的真理理论导致不同的法律方法论。符合论实在主义的哲学会导致哲学的和自然主义的法律发现,而融贯论则是规范分析和法律解释的基础。不少哲学家认为没有脱离融贯论的符合论(如普特南)。但同时,从真理的客观性维度讲,融贯论只能保障认知的客观性,而不能获得形而上的客观性。融贯论的结果必然是相对主义。因此,法律哲学的认识论选择必然是折中的,这个折中的认识论可以由普特南的内在实在主义来承担,而内在实在主义将最终引向包容的法律实证主义。 Each theory of truth entails a corresponding methodology. Realism under theory of correspondence points to the philosophical and naturalist discovery of law, whereas theory of coherence serves as the foundation of normative analysis and legal interpretation. A quite few philosophers believe the latter truth theo- ry always precedes the former one （such as Hilary Putnam）. Yet, from the perspective of objectivity, the the- ory of coherence can merely guarantee the cognizant objectivity but not the metaphysical one. The pure theory of coherence lays a road to the ineluctable relativism. Therefore, the epistemological choice of legal philosophy must be eclectic, and Putnam~ internal realism will be a qualified candidate to meet this requirement, which will lead us to the inclusive legal positivism.

作者王志远

机构地区美国纽约州立大学-宾厄姆顿分校政治系

出处《法制与社会发展》 CSSCI 北大核心 2012年第5期130-140,共11页 Law and Social Development

关键词融贯论道德实在法律内在实在主义 theory of coherence moral realism law internal realism

分类号 D90 [政治法律—法学理论]

引文网络
相关文献

参考文献43

1Hilary Putnam. Reason, Truth and History [ M ]. Cambridge, London, New York, New Rochelle, Melbourne, Sydney . Cambridge University Press, 1981.
2Donald Davidson. Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective [ MJ. New York. Oxford University Press, 2001.
3Nicholas Rescher. The Coherence Theory of Truth [ M]. London. The Clarendon Press, 1973.
4Max Weber, "Objectivity" In Social Science and Social Policy [ A]. Edward A. Shils Max Weber on the Methodology of the Social Sciences [ C]. Illinois. The Free Press of Glencoe, 1949.
5Peter T. Manicas. A Realist Philosophy of Social Science [ M ]. New York . Cambridge University Press, 2006.
6H. L. A. Hart. Positivism and the Separation of Law and Morals (First Published 1958) [ A]. Essays in Jurisprudence and Philosophy [C]. Oxford. Clarendon Press, 1983.
7H. L. A. Hart. Lon. L. Fuller. The Morality of Law (First Published 1965) [A]. Essays in Jurisprudence and Philoso- phy [C] . Oxford. Clarendon Press , 1983.
8H. L. A. Hart. The Concept of Law, 2nd ed. [M]. Oxford. Clarendon Press, 1994.
9Joseph Raz. The Authority of Law. Essays on Law and Morality [ M]. New York. Clarendon Press, 1979.
10Marmor, Andrei. Interpretation and Legal Theory [ M]. Oxford. Clarendon Press, 1992.